Wig and Pen East: Discover Iowa City’s Iconic Pizza Destination

The Ultimate Guide to Wig and Pen East: A Complete Overview of Iowa City’s Favorite Pizza Joint

Home | Wig and Pen East

Welcome to Wig and Pen East, where delicious food brings friends and family together! If you’re a pizza lover or just someone looking for a satisfying meal, you’ll find plenty to enjoy at this popular Iowa City restaurant. This guide aims to provide you with everything you need to know about Wig and Pen East, from their menu offerings to customer experiences and more.

Pizza Type Description Best For
Chicago-Style Deep Dish A hearty, thick pizza filled with layers of toppings. Fans of rich, cheesy flavors.
Thin Crust A crispy, light crust that’s perfect for dipping. Those who prefer a lighter meal.
Specialty Pizzas Unique combinations like Buffalo Chicken and Spicy Hawaiian. Adventurous eaters.
Vegetarian Options Toppings include fresh vegetables and cheeses. Vegetarians and health-conscious diners.
Appetizer Pizzas Smaller pizzas meant for sharing, great as starters. Groups and families.

Location and Hours

Wig and Pen East is conveniently located at 363 N 1st Ave, Iowa City, IA 52245. The establishment operates daily from 11:00 AM to 10:30 PM, making it an excellent choice for lunch, dinner, or late-night cravings.

WIG & PEN EAST - Updated May 2025 - 20 Photos & 40 Reviews - Yelp

Menu Highlights

Wig and Pen East offers an extensive menu that caters to various tastes. Here are some of the standout items:

Pizzas

The pizza menu is diverse, featuring options like Chicago-style deep dish and thin crust. Signature pizzas include:

  • Chicago-Style Deep Dish: Known for its “tomatoey perfection,” this pizza is a crowd favorite.
  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza: A spicy take on pizza that’s loaded with chicken and cheeses.
  • Veggie Options: Fresh ingredients like mushrooms, bell peppers, and olives are available for a lighter meal.

Appetizers

The appetizer section includes:

  • Garlic Bread: Available with or without cheese, perfect for sharing.
  • Cheese-Stuffed Breadsticks: A must-try for cheese lovers.
  • Wings: Available in various flavors, these are perfect for starting your meal.

Pasta Dishes

Wig and Pen East also serves pasta dishes, such as:

  • Wigatoni: A hearty mix of noodles, sausage, and marinara.
  • Chickatoni: A chicken and alfredo sauce version that’s equally satisfying.

Customer Experience

Pick-Up Only

While the website suggests dine-in options, customers have reported that Wig and Pen East primarily offers pick-up services. Most orders take about 25-30 minutes to prepare, ensuring a hot and fresh meal upon pick-up.

Mixed Reviews on Crust

Customers have voiced mixed opinions on the thin crust pizza. While some found it hard and chewy, others enjoyed the toppings and overall flavor. The deep-dish option consistently receives praise for its generous portions and rich taste.

Generous Portions

One common theme in reviews is the generous portion sizes. Many customers have reported leftovers after their meals, making it a budget-friendly choice.

Positive Feedback

Customers frequently mention the quality of the ingredients and the taste of the pizzas. The restaurant’s commitment to using fresh ingredients has earned them a loyal customer base.

Ordering Options

Online Ordering

You can easily order from Wig and Pen East through various platforms, including Chomp and SpotOn. This convenience allows you to choose your favorite dishes without leaving home.

Delivery Services

While the restaurant focuses on pick-up, delivery options are available through third-party apps, ensuring that you can enjoy their delicious food from the comfort of your home.

Pricing Overview

Wig and Pen East offers competitive pricing, with pizzas, appetizers, and pasta dishes generally falling within standard restaurant pricing. Most pizzas range from $14 to $24 depending on size and toppings, while appetizers are affordably priced between $6 to $12.

Menu Item Price
Half Dozen Wings $9
12″ Create Your Own Pizza $15
Chicago-Style Deep Dish $24
Cheese-Stuffed Breadsticks $7.50

Related Video

Conclusion

Wig and Pen East stands out as a top pizza destination in Iowa City, offering a wide variety of delicious pizzas, generous portions, and a commitment to quality. Whether you’re dining in or opting for pick-up, you can expect fresh ingredients and a satisfying meal. The combination of classic and unique menu items makes it a great choice for families, friends, and anyone looking for a delightful dining experience.

FAQ

What are the hours of operation for Wig and Pen East?
Wig and Pen East is open daily from 11:00 AM to 10:30 PM.

Do they offer delivery?
While primarily focused on pick-up, delivery options are available through third-party apps.

What is the most popular pizza at Wig and Pen East?
The Chicago-style deep dish pizza is often cited as a favorite among customers.

Can I customize my pizza?
Yes, customers can create their own pizzas by choosing toppings and crust types.

Is there a vegetarian menu?
Yes, Wig and Pen East offers several vegetarian options, including pizzas and appetizers.

How long does it take to prepare an order?
Most orders take about 25-30 minutes for pick-up.

Are there any gluten-free options?
The current menu does not specify gluten-free options, so it’s best to inquire directly at the restaurant.

What are the payment options available?
Wig and Pen East accepts various payment methods, including credit cards and cash.

Can I make a reservation?
Reservations are not typically required, as the restaurant operates on a first-come, first-served basis.

Is there parking available at Wig and Pen East?
Yes, there is parking available near the restaurant for customers.