Bags
Best Car Roof Bags: Comparison, Types & Buying Guide
Need extra space for your next road trip? A car roof bag is the perfect solution for travelers seeking convenience and versatility. Designed to maximize your vehicle’s cargo capacity, these durable, weather-resistant bags keep your belongings safe and organized. Discover how a car roof bag can transform your travel experience—whether for family vacations, weekend getaways, or outdoor adventures.
Car Roof Bags: A Comprehensive Comparison Table
| Type | Storage Volume | Waterproof | Rack Requirement | Suits All Vehicles | Anti-Slip Mat | Security Features | Foldable for Storage | Typical Price Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Standard Roof Bag | 15-21 cubic feet | Yes | Not always | Often | Often | Lock/Padlock | Yes | $80-$200 |
| XL/Heavy-Duty Roof Bag | 20-25+ cubic feet | Yes | Recommended | Sometimes | Yes | Reinforced Zippers | Yes | $120-$300 |
| Rackless Roof Bag | 15-21 cubic feet | Yes | No | Yes | Yes | Door Hooks | Yes | $100-$220 |
| Hitch Mount Cargo Bag | 15-20 cubic feet | Yes | No | Yes (with hitch) | No | Locks, Straps | Yes | $90-$180 |
| Soft Shell/Rigid Base Bag | 330-600 liters | Yes | Yes | Sometimes | Sometimes | Fiberglass Rigid | Sometimes | $110-$350 |
| Aerodynamic (Compact) Bag | 10-15 cubic feet | Often | Yes | Yes | Sometimes | Buckled Straps | Yes | $80-$180 |
Types of Car Roof Bags
Choosing the right car roof bag depends largely on your needs, your vehicle, and how frequently you travel. Below are the main categories you’ll encounter, along with who they suit best:
1. Standard Roof Bags
- Best for: Most family trips, general vacations, weekend getaways.
- Size: 15–21 cubic feet.
- Compatibility: Many can be used with or without roof racks.
- Features: Universal fit options, good value, usually waterproof.
2. XL and Heavy-Duty Roof Bags
- Best for: Longer trips, large families, adventure gear, camping.
- Size: 20–25+ cubic feet and up to 594L (about 21 cubic feet).
- Compatibility: May require stronger roof racks or reinforced mounting for safety.
- Features: Extra straps, enhanced waterproofing, reinforced seams.
3. Rackless Roof Bags
- Best for: Vehicles without factory-installed racks (sedans, hatchbacks).
- Compatibility: Install securely using provided door hooks and anti-slip mats.
- Features: No rack needed; come with multiple hooks and extra protection for car paint.
4. Hitch Mount Cargo Bags
- Best for: Vehicles with a hitch receiver, drivers preferring not to load roof.
- Features: Mount at the back of the car, preserving roof aerodynamics; waterproof.
5. Soft Shell/Rigid Base Roof Bags
- Best for: Anyone wanting easier installation and stability.
- Features: Rigid bases with fiberglass poles or hard panels; help maintain shape and can simplify loading/unloading.
6. Aerodynamic/Compact Roof Bags
- Best for: Occasional travelers, those prioritizing fuel economy.
- Features: Lower profiles reduce wind noise and drag; slightly smaller storage.
Material Choices for Car Roof Bags
Selecting the best car roof bag isn’t just about volume; the material dictates durability, weather resistance, and lifespan. Here’s a breakdown of popular materials:
- PVC Tarpaulin (600D-1680D):
- Heavy-duty, waterproof, rugged.
- Used in high-end models (e.g., RoofPax, Asinking).
- Resists tearing, UV rays, and harsh weather.
- Nylon (Ballistic or Reinforced):
- Tough but a little lighter than tarpaulin.
- Good tear resistance; some are water-repellent rather than fully waterproof.
- Polyester:
- Found in lower-priced models.
- Lighter, but less durable under stress or sharp edges.
- Vinyl-laminated fabrics:
- Waterproof, flexible, slightly less tough than tarpaulin.
Key Construction Features to Look For:
- Seams: Double/triple-stitched and heat-sealed for leak prevention.
- Zippers: Waterproof, oversize, often with dual covers.
- UV Protection: Ensures bag doesn’t degrade in sunlight.
- Reinforced Corners/Buckles: Security under load and repeated use.
Usage Occasions for Car Roof Bags
Car roof bags are incredibly versatile, offering extra storage for various situations:
- Family Vacations: Pack multiple suitcases, sports equipment, or camping gear.
- Camping and Outdoor Trips: Stash tents, sleeping bags, and hiking equipment.
- Moving or College Drop-Offs: Haul bulkier items you can’t fit in the trunk.
- Ski Trips: Carry skis, boots, winter gear (ensure waterproof rating).
- Road Trips with Friends or Pets: Free up cabin space, make long journeys more comfortable.
- Temporary Storage Needs: Use for shopping sprees, home improvement haulage, or seasonal travel.
Matching With Your Vehicle and Travel Style
Finding the right car roof bag isn’t just about space; it needs to fit your car well and suit your driving habits.
Consider Vehicle Type:
- Sedans & Hatchbacks: Choose bags labeled as “fits all vehicles” or specifically “rackless.”
- SUVs & Minivans: Larger bags up to 21 cubic feet or more can usually fit.
- Vehicles Without Roof Rails/Racks: Look for universal-fit bags with integrated hooks and anti-slip mats.
- Rooftop Baskets or Racks: Bags with rigid bases or corner reinforcements fit best.
Matching Travel Style:
- Frequent Adventurers: Invest in higher-grade, heavy-duty bags with extra security features (locks, robust zippers).
- Weekly Grocery Shoppers: Compact, easy-to-store bags are ideal.
- Urban Drivers: Slim, aerodynamic designs reduce city driving downsides.
Practical Tips and Best Practices
Choosing the Best Car Roof Bag:
- Check Your Vehicle’s Roof Load Limit: Always account for the combined weight of the roof bag, luggage, and racks. Overloading can damage your vehicle and void warranties.
- Measure Your Roof: Know your car’s roof length and width to avoid overhang, which could risk safety and legality.
- Plan for Waterproofing: Even short trips can encounter rain. Choose bags with 100% waterproof materials and sealed zippers.
- Prioritize Security: Opt for models with lockable zippers or provide a padlock for added peace of mind.
Installing and Using a Car Roof Bag:
- Pre-Installation: Clean your roof and check for sharp edges or dirt that may scratch the paint.
- Protective Mat: Always use an anti-slip or anti-scratch mat to avoid damage (many premium bags include one).
- Strap Tightening: Secure all provided straps tightly (but not so tight as to damage seals or racks). Periodically check and retighten after an hour of driving.
- Take Care with Door Hooks: For vehicles without racks, properly installed door hooks maintain security without compromising airbags or weather seals.
- Weatherproofing: Ensure zippers are fully closed and covers are in place before departing.
- Distribute Weight Evenly: Pack heavier items at the center and lighter ones at the ends for balance and safety.
- Monitor Speed: Be aware that large bags will increase wind noise and reduce fuel efficiency, especially above 70mph.
Maintenance and Storage:
- Dry Thoroughly: After use, dry inside and out before folding for storage to prevent mold or mildew.
- Avoid Long-Term Sun Exposure: Store away from direct sunlight between trips to extend the bag’s lifespan.
- Check Components: Examine straps, seams, and zippers for wear prior to every use.
Technical Features and Model Comparison Table
| Model/Brand | Capacity (cu ft/L) | Material | Waterproof | Fits Without Rack | Security | Anti-Slip Mat | UV-Protected | Included Accessories | Price Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RoofPax Car Roof Bag | 15/425 | 1680D PVC | Yes | Yes (Door Hooks) | TSA Lock, Door Hooks | Yes | Yes | Mat, Storage Bag, Straps, Lock | $178-198 |
| Asinking 21cu ft Bag | 21/595 | 840D Material | Yes | Yes | Luggage Lock | Yes | Yes | Anti-Slip Mat, Door Hooks, Lock | $120-180 |
| MeeFar Universal | 15/20 | 800D PVC | Yes | Yes | 4/6 Door Hooks | Yes | Yes | Mat, Storage Bag | $90-120 |
| Mockins 25/40 cu ft | 25/40 | Heavy-Duty Vinyl | Yes | Yes | Heavy Straps | Varies | Yes | Carry Bag, Accessories | $120-150 |
| Rightline Gear Range 3 | 18/509 | UV-Resistant | Yes | Yes | Lockable Zippers | Yes | Yes | Straps, Storage Bag | $100-150 |
| Marretoo Carrier | 21/594 | Waterproof PVC | Yes | Yes | Locks, Padlocks | Yes | Yes | Mat, Hooks, Straps, Bag | $100-130 |
| Fivklemnz 21 cu ft | 21/594 | Heavy-Duty Fabric | Yes | Yes | Padlock | Yes | Yes | Mat, Straps, Lock, Bag | $110-140 |
| HandiWorld HandiHoldall | 12-14/330-400 | PVC-Laminated | Yes | With Racks | Rigid Base with Poles | Sometimes | Yes | Poles, Storage Bag | $110-200 |
| Apex Rooftop Bag | 15-18 | Vinyl | Yes | Yes | Reinforced Corners | Sometimes | Yes | Straps, Accessories | $80-120 |
Related Video
Conclusion
Car roof bags are a practical, budget-friendly, and highly versatile solution for expanding your vehicle’s cargo capacity—whether you drive a compact sedan, a family SUV, or anything in between. They offer a wide range of sizes, feature robust waterproofing, and can be used with or without roof racks on most vehicles.
When shopping, prioritize key factors such as capacity, material durability, weatherproofing, and simple, secure installation. Opt for bags with anti-slip mats and lockable features to protect your vehicle and belongings. With proper installation and care, a quality car roof bag is your ticket to hassle-free vacations, outdoor adventures, and stress-free road trips.
FAQ
-
What size car roof bag do I need?
Choose a roof bag based on your vehicle’s roof size and your cargo needs. Small (10-15 cu ft) bags suit light packing or small cars. Medium (15-21 cu ft) bags fit most families. Large bags (20+ cu ft) are for group trips or extra gear. Always check your vehicle’s roof load limit before purchase. -
Are car roof bags truly waterproof?
Premium models use heavy-duty, waterproof materials (like 1680D PVC), heat-sealed seams, and water-resistant zippers. These offer robust protection against rain and snow. Some cheaper options are water-repellent, but may not withstand heavy storms. -
Can I use a car roof bag without a roof rack?
Yes, many bags are designed for vehicles without roof racks, using included door hooks and anti-slip mats. Always ensure hooks are installed correctly—never thread straps through car interiors as this can interfere with airbags or seals. -
Will a roof bag fit any vehicle type?
Most modern roof bags are “universal fit”—they can be mounted onto sedans, SUVs, trucks, and hatchbacks with or without racks. Check each product’s compatibility description and measure your roof before purchasing. -
Is there a risk of damaging my car’s paint?
Improper installation or low-cost bags can cause scratches. Minimize risk by using a quality anti-slip or anti-scratch mat between your roof and the bag, and making sure both surfaces are clean before installation. -
How does a roof bag affect fuel economy and driving?
All roof-mounted cargo solutions increase drag, which may reduce fuel efficiency—typically more so with large or boxy bags. Aerodynamic bags help reduce impact. Limit your speed, especially with large loads, and monitor wind noise. -
How do I secure a car roof bag against theft?
Look for bags with lockable zippers or add a padlock to zipper pulls. Some models include luggage locks or TSA-compliant locks for extra peace of mind. -
Can I leave a roof bag on my car when not in use?
It’s not recommended. Extended exposure to weather can degrade the bag, and empty bags may move or flap while driving. Remove the bag when not in use, dry it thoroughly, and store it in its storage bag.
-
How do I install a car roof bag safely?
Follow the manufacturer’s instructions closely. Secure all straps or door hooks, tighten them evenly, and recheck after driving for some time. Use all included safety and protective features like mats and locks. -
How do I clean and store my roof bag after use?
Empty all contents, shake out debris, and wash the bag with mild soap and water (avoid harsh detergents). Let it dry completely before folding, then store in a cool, dry place—ideally in the provided storage bag to prevent mildew or tearing.
