Old Bag of Nails Menu Guide: Prices, Top Picks & Options

Discover the charm of the Old Bag of Nails menu—a treasure trove for food lovers seeking classic pub fare with a twist. This shopping guide delves into their mouthwatering offerings, from hearty burgers to fresh seafood, making it easy for you to choose your next meal. Whether you’re a regular or a first-timer, find out what makes this menu a local favorite.

Old Bag of Nails Menu Comparison Table

Category	Signature Dishes	Price Range	Dietary Options	Family-Friendly	Portion Size	Popular Sides	Vegetarian Options
Starters & Appetizers	Spinach & Artichoke Dip, Potstickers, Beer-Battered Pickles, Cheese Curds, Loaded Potato Skins, Potato Cakes	$6.99 – $13	Some items vegetarian	Yes	Sharable	Ranch, Marinara, Chips	Yes
Wings	Chicken Wings, Boneless Wings, Dry Rub Options	$7 – $16	Gluten-free (some)	Yes	By count	Celery, Blue Cheese	No
Seafood & Fish & Chips	Famous Fish & Chips, Shrimp & Chips, Atlantic Salmon, Mussels & Shrimp, Fish Sandwich, Tacos	$14.99 – $22	Gluten-free options	Yes	Generous	Coleslaw, Fries	Limited
Pub Fare & Sandwiches	Pub Reuben, Philly Cheesesteak, Chicken Sandwiches, French Dip	$8.99 – $18	Some light options	Yes	Substantial	Fries, Soup, Chips	Some (Portobello)
Burgers & Mini Burgers	Gaylord’s Favorite, Cowboy, Blackened, Rustic	$7.99 – $15.5	Customizable cheeses	Yes	½ lb. patties	Fries, Onion Rings	No
Salads & Soups	Chicken Cobb, Caesar, Greek, Pub House Salad, Wedge, Clam Chowder, French Onion	$3.99 – $20	Vegetarian, add-ons	Yes	Small/Large	House Dressings	Yes
Quesadillas & Wraps	Spicy Chicken, Vegetable Quesadilla, Buffalo Chicken Wrap	$7.99 – $14	Vegetarian available	Yes	Main/Shared	Salsa, Sour Cream, Chips	Yes
Sides	Onion Rings, Tater Tots, Sweet Potato Fries, Wild Rice, Apple Sauce, Steamed Veggies	$1.99 – $4.75	Many vegetarian	Yes	Small	–	Yes
Desserts	Carrot Cake, Bread Pudding, Fried Snickers, Ice Cream Ball	$2.99 – $4.99	Some nut-free options	Yes	Shareable	–	Yes
Kids Meals	Fish & Chips, Chicken Tenders, Mini Burgers	Varies	Simple, kid-friendly	Yes	Smaller	Fries, Fruit, Chips	Yes

---

Types of Offerings on the Old Bag of Nails Menu

Selecting from the Old Bag of Nails menu is like embarking on a flavorful journey through classic British pub fare, freshly prepared seafood, and robust comfort food. Here’s a detailed breakdown of the types you’ll find:

Starters and Favorites

Perfect for sharing or kickstarting your meal, these include classics such as:
– Spinach and Artichoke Dip
– Beer-Battered Mushrooms and Pickle Spears
– Potato Skins
– Bavarian Pretzels with Beer Cheese
– Wisconsin Cheese Curds

Wings

Wings come traditional or boneless, with a variety of rubs and sauces (from Nashville Hot to Garlic Parmesan), served by the pound or half-pound.

Seafood and Fish & Chips

At the heart of the menu:
– Famous Fish & Chips (hand-battered Atlantic fish)
– Shrimp & Chips (with all-you-can-eat Wednesdays)
– Fisherman’s Platter (fish and shrimp combo)
– Grilled or blackened Atlantic Salmon, Mussels & Shrimp, and Shrimp Po’boy

Pub Fare and Sandwiches

Robust sandwiches and pub classics:
– House-cooked Corned Beef Reuben, Turkey Reuben, New England Reuben
– Philly Cheesesteak (prime rib, chicken, or ground beef)
– French Dip
– Chicken Tenders & Buffalo Chicken Wraps

Burgers & Mini Burgers

Hearty offerings include:
– Gaylord’s Favorite (bacon, cheddar, BBQ sauce)
– The Rustic (blue cheese, bacon, onion straws)
– Customizable half-pound burgers
– Mini versions for lighter appetites or sharing

Salads & Soups

Large salads can serve as meals, with protein add-ons:
– Cobb, Caesar, Spinach, Wedge, Greek
– House-made Clam Chowder, French Onion, Soup of the Day

Quesadillas & Wraps

Tex-Mex flavors including:
– Spicy Chicken or Veggie Quesadillas with sides of salsa and sour cream
– Chicken Caesar and Buffalo Chicken Wraps

Sides

A wide assortment including:
– Sweet Potato Fries, Onion Rings, Tater Tots, Kettle Chips, Wild Rice, Steamed Veggies

Desserts

Finish with carrot cake, bread pudding, or a fun treat like Fried Snickers.

Kids’ Menu

Family-focused with smaller portions of classics like fish and chips, burgers, and chicken tenders.

---

Material Choices: Ingredients and Preparation Style

The appeal of Old Bag of Nails dishes comes from their quality ingredients and preparation methods:

• Seafood Sourcing: Atlantic cod, freshwater white fish, and shrimp, prepared to order (battered, grilled, blackened).
• Breads: Hoagie rolls, marble rye, sourdough, ciabatta, and tortillas for wraps.
• Cheeses: Wide selection (cheddar, Swiss, provolone, American, blue, pepper jack, feta), used in melts, burgers, and dips.
• Fresh Vegetables: Lettuce, tomatoes, onions (including house-pickled), spinach, mushrooms, slaw.
• House Sauces: Ranging from Cajun mayo, hot bacon vinaigrette, dill cream sauce, aiolis, beer cheese, buffalo and specialty wing sauces.
• Hand-Battering: Proudly features hand-battered mushrooms, fish, pickles, and onion rings, lending an authentic pub feel.
• Meats: House-carved corned beef, prime rib for cheesesteaks, grilled or fried chicken breast.
• Custom Dressings: OBON house vinaigrette, French, Ranch, Blue Cheese, Caesar, 1000 Island.

---

Usage Occasions: When to Enjoy Old Bag of Nails Menu

Old Bag of Nails excels at meeting a diverse range of mealtime needs:

1. Family Gatherings

Large portions, shareable appetizers, and a kid’s menu make it a favorite for families. Sunday “Kids Eat Free” specials further enhance its family-friendly vibe.

2. Casual Lunches

Lunch specials offer half portions of favorites like grilled cheese, ribeye sandwiches, fish baskets, and tacos, with a choice of soup or side for a quick and satisfying midday break.

3. After-Work and Game Day

Craft beers, a full bar, and appetizers like nachos, wings, and loaded potato skins make it an ideal place to unwind or watch the game with friends.

4. Date Nights & Celebrations

Seafood platters, steaks, and rich desserts turn any evening into a special occasion.

5. Takeout and Delivery

Robust packaging and classic comfort food make it a strong choice for at-home dining, whether ordering online for pickup or delivery.

6. Catering & Parties

Platters of wings, mini burgers, or salads offer crowd-pleasing options for group events.

---

How to Match with Outfits: Occasion-Based Dining Style

While not a literal fashion guide, choosing from the Old Bag of Nails menu can influence the mood of your gathering, much like picking an outfit for the occasion:

• Casual, Social Outings: Opt for shareable starters, wings, and burgers—laid-back, approachable choices for jeans-and-t-shirt affairs.
• Business Lunches: Try salads or pub sandwiches, presenting a more refined, balanced option without being too formal.
• Special Celebrations: Seafood platters, steaks, and desserts represent the “dressy” side of the menu—go for an elevated dining experience.
• Family Meals with Kids: Kids’ baskets, fries, and mini burgers keep things light, playful, and practical, just like weekend wear.
• At-Home or Takeout: Comfort classics like fish and chips echo the cozy, relaxed outfit you’d wear while dining at home.

---

Practical Tips and Best Practices for Choosing and Using the Old Bag of Nails Menu

Here’s how to maximize your visit and get the best out of the menu:

1. Check for Daily Specials and Events
2. All-you-can-eat shrimp & chips on Wednesdays.
3. Kids eat free on Sundays.

4. Seasonal cocktails and featured beers (like $5 Modelo drafts).

5. Pair Dishes Thoughtfully

6. Seafood pairs well with crisp salads and light sides.

7. Burgers go best with fries, tater tots, or onion rings.

8. Customization is Welcome

9. Burgers and sandwiches can be customized with cheese, sauces, or blackening spices.

10. Many salads and wraps offer protein add-ons (chicken, shrimp, salmon).

11. Ask About Dietary Preferences

12. Vegetarian-friendly selections include salads, potato cakes, black bean dips, cheese curds, veggie quesadillas, and more.

13. Gluten-free soups (clam chowder), grilled proteins, and some sides are available.

14. Portion Sizes are Generous

15. Keep this in mind when ordering starters or platters—sharing is encouraged!

16. Take Advantage of Loyalty Programs

17. Join the rewards club for discounts, birthday perks, and exclusive offers.

18. Utilize Online Ordering

19. For takeout or delivery, utilize user-friendly online ordering or the mobile app for convenience.

20. Inquire About Seasonal Plates

21. Some locations offer rotating specials, holiday desserts, or limited-edition entrees.

22. For Groups, Order Platters

23. Large gatherings benefit from orders of wings, fries, and shareable apps.

24. Don’t Overlook Dessert

    • House-made carrot cake and bread pudding are standouts—save room!

---

Feature Comparison Table: Key Attributes of Old Bag of Nails Menu Categories

Menu Category	Main Ingredients	Portion Style	Dietary Options	Signature Preparation	Side Choices	Takeout Friendly
Fish & Chips	Atlantic fish, potatoes, batter	Platter/Basket	Fried, can be “spicy”	Hand-battered, fried or blackened	Steak fries, coleslaw, tartar	Yes
Shrimp Platters	Jumbo shrimp, steak fries, slaw	Platter	Fried, Blackened	Hand-battered, Fried	Fries, cocktail sauce	Yes
Sandwiches	Beef, chicken, fish, cheese, bread	Individually served	Grilled, Fried, Blackened	Variety: grilled, fried, blackened	Fries, chips, coleslaw	Yes
Burgers	Ground beef, variety of cheeses, toppings	½ lb. patties	Customizable	Grilled to order, blackened upon request	Fries, side salad	Yes
Salads	Romaine/spinach, eggs, bacon, cheese, dressing	Bowl (small/large)	Vegetarian/protein add-ons	Fresh cut, house dressings	Add grilled items, soups	Yes
Wings	Chicken wings, dry rubs or sauces	10 count/1 lb.	Boneless, bone-in	Fried, sauced to order	Celery, blue cheese	Yes
Apps & Starters	Cheese, dip, veggies, breads	Sharable	Some vegetarian	Fried or baked; various dips	Marinara, ranch, tortilla chips	Yes
Desserts	Carrot cake, Snickers, pudding, ice cream	Individually/split	Some nut-free options	Made in-house, daily (varies)	–	Yes
Kids’ Menu	Fish, chicken, burgers, fries	Small plates	Simple preparations	Fried or grilled	Fries, fruit, chips	Yes

---

Related Video

Conclusion

The Old Bag of Nails menu delivers an authentic taste of classic pub fare fused with American comfort and British tradition. Whether you’re in the mood for expertly battered seafood, a hearty sandwich, or something lighter like a salad, there’s a carefully crafted dish for every appetite and occasion. Generous portions, diverse options (including vegetarian and gluten-free), and thoughtful touches like kids’ specials and house-made desserts distinguish this menu.

For families, groups, and solo diners alike, the Old Bag of Nails offers consistent quality, flexible ordering (dine-in, takeout, or delivery), and a charming pub ambience. By referencing the guidance above—on menu categories, ideal usage occasions, customization opportunities, and pairings—you’ll be well-equipped to make delicious, satisfying choices with every visit.

---

FAQ

1. What are the signature dishes at Old Bag of Nails?
   The most renowned dishes include the Famous Fish & Chips, hand-battered Shrimp & Chips (with all-you-can-eat specials on Wednesdays), Fisherman’s Platter, the Pub Reuben, and Gaylord’s Favorite Burger.

2. Do they offer vegetarian options?
   Yes, vegetarians can enjoy salads, potato cakes, cheese curds, black bean dip, veggie quesadillas, onion rings, tater tots, and select sides. Some locations may feature rotating vegetarian specials as well.

3. Are there gluten-free options available?
   Several menu items are gluten-free or can be modified, including New England Clam Chowder, most salads (request no croutons), grilled proteins, and certain sides. Always ask your server for the most current gluten-free choices.

4. Does Old Bag of Nails have a kid’s menu?
   Absolutely! The kid’s menu features smaller portions of popular dishes such as fish and chips, chicken tenders, and mini burgers—ideal for family outings.

1. How are the portion sizes?
   Portions are generous across the menu. Many appetizers and platters are suitable for sharing, and the salads and burgers can serve as hearty main courses.

2. Are daily specials and loyalty programs available?
   Yes. Specials such as all-you-can-eat shrimp or fish & chips, “Kids Eat Free” on Sundays, featured beers and cocktails, and a robust rewards program with discounts and perks are offered.

3. Is online ordering and delivery available?
   Most locations offer convenient online ordering, in-store pickup, and delivery via web and mobile app. Third-party services may also deliver from select locations.

4. What sides can I choose with my meal?
   Standard sides include steak fries, thin fries, kettle chips, coleslaw, tater tots, wild rice, sweet potato fries, onion rings, steamed broccoli, sautéed veggies, applesauce, and more. Premium sides and salads are available for a small upcharge.

5. Are there options for dietary customization?
   Definitely. Many dishes allow you to substitute proteins (like switching from grilled to blackened chicken), request additional toppings, or swap sides. Don’t hesitate to ask for modifications to suit your preferences.

6. What desserts are recommended?
   House-made carrot cake, bread pudding a la mode, fried Snickers, and pecan-crusted ice cream balls are top picks to round off your meal with something sweet and memorable.